Feed for this Forum

Discussion Forum

Get a Gravatar from gravatar.com

United Future
Since: 2007-08-08 10:30:45.829588
Posts: 220

Feed for this Topic

BLOG:

The Children's Commissioner's plans for mandatory inspection of young children to see if they are suffering from child abuse is the wrong answer
to the right question. She is right to be concerned that young and vulnerable children are being abused and that this is not being discovered
until it is too late. But mandatory inspection, especially by a state agency like Child,Youth & Family is not the answer. Instead, what we ought
to be doing is empowering voluntary organisations like Plunket to carry out more home visits, and for their assessments of family circumstances to
carry more weight than they do already. Cindy Kiro's solution may not be acceptable, but at least she recognises there is a problem requiring a
solution, a point which seems to have escaped Family First altogether with the "butt out and leave this to parents" approach Bob McCoskrie was
pushing. That is precisely the type of approach that saw the neighbours stand by and do nothing while little Nia Glassie was pegged on the clothes
line next door. Doing nothing, or leaving it all to parents is, sadly, not the way to stop child abuse. Read the full text of this blog post.

Get a Gravatar from gravatar.com

John Pickering
Since: 2007-08-16 12:06:16.857
Posts: 16

I agree CYFs is the wrong agency - the environment there is to assume guilt first - not something appropriate for the vast majority of parents.

The attitude of neighbours standing by and doing nothing is not limited to child abuse. We see it with racist taunts towards Asians, petty theft etc where those who could get involved, don't. It is symptomatic of a culture that has elevated personal rights up above responsibility towards others. For this reason, I think the "it's not OK" message of the anti-abuse campaign misses the mark. That campaign is aimed at people who probably know it is not OK already and it encourages them to do something about it (a difficult step). Rather, a campaign directed at the rest of us who need to get involved when we see something that we even mildly suspect may be wrong, would be more effective.

Please login to post a reply.