Feed for this Forum

Discussion Forum

Get a Gravatar from gravatar.com

United Future
Since: 2007-08-08 10:30:45.829588
Posts: 220

Feed for this Topic

Best laid welfare plans can go bad - Dunne

UnitedFuture has responded cautiously to National’s welfare plan, with leader Peter Dunne warning that the plan risks being overly punitive and harsh in practice.

“We are talking here about some of our most vulnerable citizens, those with illness or disabilities and single parents with dependant children,” says Mr Dunne.

“Good ideas can easily get overtaken by the hard-liners, so that the policy becomes too harsh and inflexible as a result.

“Creating work obligations for those sickness beneficiaries who can work a little may appear fine on paper, but the danger remains that this policy could easily become somewhat ruthless in practice if some of the more right-wing elements of National are charged with its action.

“In many other areas, the policy focus has been on making it easier for parents with dependant children to spend more time at home in their child’s formative years, but National’s emphasis on getting single parents back into the workforce quickly could be seen as running counter to this.

“These changes highlight the need for a moderate Government approach, something which at this point is unproven and will have many beneficiaries sleeping a little less soundly tonight,” says Mr Dunne.
Read the full text of this article.

Get a Gravatar from gravatar.com

mcinnes
Since: 2008-04-02 17:40:05.946
Posts: 49

Dunne does have a good handle on common sense. Shame some of those looking on can't see the wood for the trees & don't! I understand that both Labour & National see him & his party as the preferred coalition/agreement partner. Reading this article it's easy to see why even though his challenging both of those parties to bring a better balance with MMP & the likes of Social Welfare & taxation means they will have to allow some limitations to Labour or National's more extreme stances & ideas. They might not want to but it appears Dunne will again try to have common sense reign supreme! Isn't that what a true centre party does rather than run around like so many others with a blunt axe doing its hatchet jobs on any & all who it can 'bully' to try & win a vote from its established constituency by shoving it to those that don't historically & won't vote for them

Get a Gravatar from gravatar.com

Quentin Todd
Since: 2007-11-03 07:27:50.433
Posts: 68

Send email

As I am on the Invalids Benefit for Chronic Fatique Syndrome and mild Depression, I believe Peter Dunne is right about two things and I am a case study in that. One, there is already a system with WINZ where they help me look for employment to the tune of 15 hours a week. I was offered a job three years ago on that note for a not for profit organization. It is funded 50% by Workbridge and the organization pays the 50% without my losing the benefit- I thank God for that because the cost of living is extreme. I would love to work full time but not sure I have the ability to. So National's plan is not very well researched in that department.

Two, getting single parents into work is a disaster in stress management. It is right that the practice of making single parents work is quite harsh as it is for sickness beneficiaries being forced back into work. People who deal with WINZ knows that fear of losing an income by the power the department has in the name of bureaucracy is what really matters- to be made to do something is not ever going to work and National has always had this kind of policy in the name of economic growth- they have always had in for people on benefits.If they get away with that kind of policy which I know they won't have the numbers- then we could see a brand new kind of mafia in this country

Please login to post a reply.